Renters Insurance Rochester NY

This article includes links which we may receive compensation for if you click, at no cost to you.

If you’ve chosen to call Rochester, NY, home, you could be missing out on one of the most affordable insurance policies you can buy.

While homeowners insurance is required by most lenders, the same isn’t always true of renters insurance.

However, the need to protect your stuff from damage or theft (and yourself from liability) is just as important for renters as it is for homeowners.

Although landlords have to carry insurance policies, there’s a lot those policies don’t cover, like your personal belongings.

In the post below, we’ll break down the basics of renters insurance, pointing you to the top renters insurance companies in Rochester and sharing some data on renting in the city.

Top 7 Renters Insurance Companies in Rochester

Rochester residents have access to coverage from some of the nation’s best renters insurance companies.

We’ve compared several companies based on their customer experience, coverage, and cost, narrowing down the dozens of renters companies in Rochester to the top 7 featured here.

  1. 🏆  Allstate: Best All-Around Renters Insurance in Rochester, NY
  2. Lemonade: Best Online Experience
  3. Liberty Mutual: Best Discounts
  4. Stillwater: Best Customization
  5. State Farm: Best Customer Experience
  6. Travelers: Best Comprehensive Coverage
  7. USAA: Best Military Coverage


Allstate is the top provider for Rochester residents, with great coverage at low rates and an impressive lineup of products.

If you’re looking for more than renters insurance, you can easily bundle your policy with auto insurance.

You can also access life, auto, pet, business, and more lines of insurance.

You also get to work with a local agent who can assist you every step of the way. Alongside a user-friendly app and website, Allstate’s agents add to its stellar claims process.

Allstate offers some additional coverage options, like scheduled property riders and flood insurance as well.


  • Claims process
  • Cheap coverage
  • Local agents
  • Additional coverage


If you’re looking for a forward-thinking renters insurance experience that streamlines the process with online tools, Lemonade is your go-to.

Over the last few years, Lemonade has provided policyholders with affordable basic renters policies starting at $5 a month that are effortless to manage.

Lemonade also states that you could file a claim online and get paid in as little as 3 minutes, thanks to its AI-based claims center.

In addition to offering you peace of mind and protection, Lemonade is dedicated to giving back.

Excess premium payments get donated to a charity of your choosing at the end of the year, so you can feel even better about investing in a renters policy.


  • Give-back initiative
  • Quick claims process
  • User-friendly website
  • Cheap coverage

Learn More:

Liberty Mutual

A  name you’re likely familiar with, thanks to its national presence and marketing efforts, is Liberty Mutual.

A provider that offers a full suite of insurance products, Liberty is another company ideal for bundling policies.

There are several ways you can save with Liberty Mutual, including:

  • Multi-policy discount
  • Claims-free discount
  • Early shopper discount
  • Automatic payment discount
  • Online purchase discount

You’ll also get coverage that is easy to customize, with a handful of endorsements and full replacement cost coverage.


  • Discounts
  • Additional products
  • Flexible coverage
  • Online claims center

Learn More:


While it might not be quite as well-known as some of its competitors, Stillwater is a solid choice for renters in Rochester.

By comparison, it offers some of the best rates on renters insurance in the state of New York.

The company also offers policies that are very customizable, with several optional add-ons.

For instance, you can add scheduled property protection and even get coverage for damage done to your rental property by your pet.

Stillwater also offers a full range of insurance products, including umbrella insurance, if you’re looking for more expansive, comprehensive coverage.


  • Low rates
  • Customizable policies
  • Additional coverage
  • Other insurance products

State Farm

State Farm takes the prize for customer experience, with some of the highest J.D. Power ratings and a great claims process.

If you’re looking for a personalized experience with access to multiple lines of communication, State Farm is a wise choice.

With State Farm, you get everything you might expect from a top-tier national provider, from local agents to several discounts, to multiple policy options.

State Farm’s renters policies are well-priced for Rochester residents as well, offering decent rates for its basic policies and more extensive coverage.


  • Customer experience
  • Bundling discounts
  • Online quotes
  • Local agents

Learn More:


Travelers is one of your best bets if you’re looking to go beyond basic renters insurance.

Travelers lets you add several additions to your policy, one of the most unique being improvements coverage.

With this feature, you can apply as much as 10% of your personal property coverage to home improvement, if the damage is due to a covered peril or you’re responsible for it.

You can also get total cost replacement and add extra coverage to pricier items.

As a multi-policy provider, Travelers also offers discounts for bundling, as well as savings for arming your home with security features.


  • Home improvement coverage
  • Endorsements
  • Customer service
  • Multi-policy savings

Learn More:


Last but not least, USAA is a smart call if you belong to a military family.

The company has close to a century of experience under its belt of offering excellent financial products to military members, vets, and their loved ones.

With USAA, you get on-the-go worldwide coverage that protects your stuff whether you’re moving across the country or it’s stowed away in storage.

It also includes flood insurance in its basic policy, an option that most providers do not.

USAA’s strongest feature is its customer experience. The company has received J.D. Power’s highest honors for its commitment to its customers.


  • Customer experience
  • On-the-go protection
  • Flood protection
  • Full replacement cost

Learn More:

Why You Need Renters Insurance in Rochester

Renters insurance is a must, even though it isn’t a legal requirement like car insurance.

Without a policy in place, you could be on the hook for hundreds or thousands of dollars if bad weather, theft, or an accident takes place at your apartment.

For all the coverage it provides, renters insurance is surprisingly affordable, usually ranging from about $10 to $20 a month.

At its core, a basic renters insurance policy provides you with the following:

  • Personal property protection, which can pay to replace your stuff if it is stolen, destroyed, or damaged.
  • Additional living expenses, which kicks in if your house is unlivable after being damaged by a covered peril, paying for your food, housing, and any other basic living expenses.
  • Liability coverage, which shields you from legal and medical costs if you are responsible for damage to someone’s property or their wellbeing.
  • Medical expense coverage, which protects you and your house guests if one of you is accidentally injured on your property.

Beyond these basic coverages, you may be able to add more layers of protection, from additional perils like water backup and flood protection to scheduled property riders for expensive individual items.

One of the largest cities in New York, Rochester, is more susceptible to burglaries than some more rural areas, all the more reason to purchase a policy.

How Much is Renters Insurance in Rochester?

What you pay for renters insurance will depend on several factors.

The best way to get a clear idea of how much renters insurance will cost you in Rochester is to get quotes.

But in general, your rates will be based on:

  • Your location: The area of Rochester you live in can influence the cost of coverage, factoring in crime rates, and even how close you are to a police or fire department.
  • Property type: The type of structure you live in could play a role in determining what you pay for your policy, too.
  • Security measures: Having an alarm system in place can get you lower rates as it reduces the risk of robbery.
  • Coverage: How much coverage you buy, what additions you purchase, and what deductible you’re willing to pay will largely set your rates.
  • Company: With each company defining risk differently and offering its own range of discounts, which company you choose could make a big difference in premiums.
  • Claims history: The company will also look at your track record with renters insurance claims. The more likely you are to file a claim, the higher your rates could be.

The average cost of renters insurance in Rochester, New York, is about $10, which amounts to $125 a year.

Rochester residents pay less for renters insurance than individuals living in other major cities across the state like Buffalo and New York City.

Compare Renters Insurance Companies In Your Area
Enter your zip code to get started

Is Renters Insurance in Rochester Worth It?

Accidents happen all too often, and unfortunately, they can end up costing thousands of dollars.

Renters insurance can be a lifesaver when life takes an unexpected turn, protecting everything from your great-grandmother’s locket to your living room furniture.

If you live in Rochester, you can secure your belongings and shield yourself from liability at minimal cost to you.

Renters insurance is a no-brainer, assuring you that your most treasured belongings are safe, no matter what life throws your way.

At the very least, you won’t regret comparing quotes from some of the top-notch providers at your disposal.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

In This Article